Producing WhiskyCast has given me the opportunity to taste some really amazing whiskies, and I’m pleased to share my tasting notes with you here. You can search my entire database of tasting notes from this page, and I hope you’ll find it useful.
My scoring system is completely subjective, and I don’t pretend that it’s anything else. I score based on my impressions of a whisky’s nose, taste, and finish. I want something discernible in all three — in other words, a whisky that noses and tastes well, but has a flat finish will score less than what I consider a well-balanced whisky that has all three elements in tune.
I’ve often been accused of being a “high scorer”, but let me explain the scale I use for assigning scores. I decided to use the same scale as the academically rigorous high school my daughters attended. While most high schools would rank any grade above 90 as an “A” and scores between 80 and 90 as a “B”, our school sets the bar higher at 93 points for an “A” and 85 points for a “B”. By the way, an “A+” is anything 97 points or higher. Using that scale, only 23 of the 1,200 whiskies listed here would get an “A+” grade. Here’s how the scale works:
Finally, please don’t take these ratings as anything more than what they are: the grade of one individual whisky lover. If you want to use them as a guide, that’s fine…but remember that everyone has his or her own sense of what a great whisky should be, and these scores are nothing more than my own academic exercise in that pursuit. There is no way to fairly compare scores and notes from different whisky critics, since each of us has our own unique sensory memories and scoring methods.
You can search by the brand name of a whisky, distillery, or a specific country using the “name” and “country” boxes only.
Scotland and the USA (and use “USA”, not “United States”) are the only countries with regional designations, and entering terms like “Speyside” or “Kentucky” in the region box will return whiskies from those regions only.
“Type” refers to the type of whisky, such as Single Malt (all countries), Blended Scotch, Bourbon, etc. “Bottler” refers to the company responsible for bottling the whisky, and official distillery bottlings are labeled as “Distiller”.
You can also enter the name of an independent bottler in this box to see results for that specific company, such as Gordon & MacPhail or Duncan Taylor.
Finally, entering a number in the “Score” field will return all whiskies with that specific score.
A California federal judge has dismissed the class-action lawsuit against Maker's Mark over the "handmade" claim on its label. Judge John Houston used the same logic as a Florida judge did in dismissing a similar lawsuit in May...that no reasonable consumer would interpret the "handmade" claim to believe that no equipment was used at all to make the whisky.
More details (and the PDF of the ruling) are available at our web site...
The Kentucky State Fire Marshal's office has released its report on the April 24 Silver Trail Distillery explosion, and is ruling it accidental. However, the report found that the Revenoor Still that exploded was installed with a pressure relief valve rated for use on home water heaters and not suited for use on a still. That valve was designed to release pressure at 210º Fahrenheit and 75psi, while the still's maker told investigators his welds would start to crack at 4-5psi.
You'll find more details on the report and a link to download a copy at our web site...
July 28, 2015 - Investigators with the Kentucky State Fire Marshal's office have ruled the April 24 explosion at the Silver Trail Distillery an accident, but blame a pressure relief valve as a like...