Tasting Notes
Producing WhiskyCast has given me the opportunity to taste some really amazing whiskies, and these tasting notes are how I share that experience with you. It’s a privilege to experience those “once in a lifetime,” expressions, but those aren’t my favorites. More meaningful to me are the whiskies which we pour each day, and the ones over which we share time together…the whiskies which are accessible to most enthusiasts.
The Whisky Search
Ralph Waldo Emerson had it right: “it’s not the destination, it’s the journey.” So it is with whisky…at least we think so!
You can search the database of tasting notes from this page by completing at least one search criteria in the form. We encourage you to always include a score or score range for your desired results.
More About Scoring Whisky
We score based on impressions of a whisky’s nose, taste, and finish. The goal is to find something discernible in all three — in other words, a whisky that noses and tastes well, but has a flat finish will score less than a well-balanced whisky that has all three elements in tune. Our scoring scale reflects the fact that for a whisky to have been bottled in the first place, someone had to like it enough to put their reputation on the line. We use the same scale as our local high school, which is known for being academically rigorous: 93 points for an “A” and 85 points for a “B”. An “A+” is anything 97 points or higher. Our Tasting Notes are the grade of one individual whisky lover. Everyone has his or her own sense of what a great whisky should be, and these scores are nothing more than my own academic exercise in that pursuit. Each of us has our own unique sensory memories and scoring metrics.
How to Taste Whisky
Whisky is meant to be enjoyed, and with thoughtful savoring, you can discover the many flavors of whisky. To help you with get started on your whisky exploration, here are our recommendations on how whisky is best served:
- At ambient room temperature and after it has settled from a lot of motion;
- In a glass which has a bowl to allow the spirit to breathe but a narrow opening so you can smell and capture the aroma;
- First experience the spirit undiluted as bottled; then if desired, a small amount of room temperature pure or bottled water can be added to the spirit.
We encourage you to cup your whisky glass and allow the warmth of your hands to help open up the spirit in both scent and taste.
RECENT ADDITIONS
The Balvenie Sweet Toast of American Oak
Score:
93
This is part of The Balvenie's 2019 "Stories" range and was created by Apprentice Malt...
Dry Fly Port Finish Wheat Whiskey
Score:
90
This takes the standard 3-year-old Dry Fly Washington Wheat Whiskey and gives it between six...
Irish Whiskey Society Marrowbone Lane Edition
Score:
95
This Single Pot Still cask was distilled at Midleton in 2005 and bottled in 2016...
Mortlach 16 “Distiller’s Pride”
Score:
93
This is one of the three whiskies in the revamped Mortlach range that debuted in...
Mortlach 12 “The Wee Witchie”
Score:
92
This is the "entry-level" bottling in the Mortlach range unveiled by Diageo in 2018, and...
Distillery 291 Colorado Straight Bourbon
Score:
94
This Bourbon may be even harder to find than the vaunted Pappy Van Winkle, since...
Templeton Rye Barrel Strength 2019 Edition
Score:
91
This whiskey has a nose full of baking spices, an herbal hint of dill, straw,...
Booker’s Bourbon Batch 2019-2 “Shiny Barrel Batch”
Score:
93
This batch of Booker's gets its name from the days when rickhouse workers might illicitly...
George Dickel Bottled in Bond (Fall 2005)
Score:
91
There's nothing that says a Bottled in Bond whisky can't be a lot older than...
Blood Oath Pact No. 5
Score:
93
The 2019 edition of Blood Oath takes 8-year-old rye-forward Bourbon finished in Caribbean Rum casks...

